.ml is an authoritarian dictatorship that simps for Russia, and .world is a wannabe Reddit clone that simps for .ml
Beans.
You’re going to encounter some viewpoints that you’ll rarely see on reddit. This may come as quite a shock to you. Many people are tempted to blame this on “bots”, which doesn’t stand up to reason. Imagine you want to influence public opinion through a bot campaign. How high would Lemmy rank on your priority list? Keep an open mind, and don’t assume that opinions that challenge your own are disingenuous.
Idk, I read the person that made lemmy was an extremist, and they can do loads of things to push their agenda besides “bots.”
Sure, I guess they probably could. But what for example? I see a lot of complaints about “bots”. I don’t know if people genuinely believe it, but I see it a lot.
This isn’t the Lemmy core code, but the Tesseract front end client blocking certain instances with a hard-coded list is a good example of the kinds of things that could be done by a developer.
And the XZ Utils hack shows how deeply the issue could be buried…that one was only found because someone wondered why SSH logins were taking a few more milliseconds.
I don’t see why someone wouldn’t run bots here - after they are set up, it’s minimal upkeep on them, isn’t it? If you wanted to sway opinions, why not run them here?
Because of the limited impact? Look at Facebook and Reddit: huge platforms with well-documented bot problems. Look what they are pushing. Liberalism and fascism. Leftist and anti imperialist views not only aren’t being pushed, they are actively suppressed. Who would run leftist bots on Lemmy, that wouldn’t bother running them on larger platforms? If Lemmy were just as much a target for bots as those other platforms, why is the flavor of conversation here so obviously different?
To push extremist content and make it seem valid and popular and spread its hostilities like a plague through the herd.
Extremism like say, support for the global hegemon and its status quo of genocide and war-profiteering? That is what you get everywhere else.
Every instance hates every other instance, but none more than .ML and .world hate each other
It’s like being on Reddit except every single user is a militant leftist trans person who uses linux and has zero social skills
And it’s all the better for it
Hey, I’m not trans!

I knew that someone was going to say this, but I could not have imagined that this would be how 😂
… Yet.
Don’t forget that this person is also vegan and OBVIOUSLY neurodivergent why are you judging fish on their ability to climb trees Einstein wasn’t good at math what are we talking about again?
You can literally type the word “FUCK” and “DIED” and literally nobody from Lemmy is coming to your door to arrest you. You don’t have to c*ns*r every other word that might offend someone living on the other side of the world and who has limited access to the internet and probably won’t ever see your post on Lemmy. It’s freeing.
Yeah. But this is .world where use of the word “tankie” is reported and removed more often than not. They’re trying HARD to be Reddit.
Yeah, that’s one downside. There’s a much higher level of mod/admin attitude (or floofy pride, whatver) here than on Reddit. They’ll ban you for practically nothing on Reddit, but they’ll ban you for literally nothing here. So, pick your poison I guess.
We have different experiences here. Call out a tankie and they remove comments. Yet the tankies are free to spread their propaganda far and wide as long as their civil™ about it.
The mods also are allowed to harass via moldings with no accountability. You can be accused of shit you are provenly NOT, but the mods get the final say and the admins won’t do shit about it.
FUCK
/Runs away and hides
Oi, a hearty FUCK to you to mate. Cheers!
You can also say shit like “beat the fucker with a tyre iron” and not have an IPO Protection Bot lodge in your colon
I started seeing people using the phrase “deleted” on YouTube real time chats and I wondered what was going on. Turns out “killed” is another banned word over there. :)
[Deleted by the Cybermen]
[ Removed by Moderator ]
Just kidding.
username checks out
Except on the original instance, the one actually run by the developers of the Lemmy software. There it’s all removed this and removed.
please read the articles before commenting
No no, that would be different than the usual, we want them to fit in! Don’t tell them that!
Can I ask some ELI5 questions, people might wonder (that I don’t think I could explain as well as others can)
- What are instances, really tho?
- Also I notice some instances have reputations (let’s not go there, but) what are some super mild instance suggestions for new people to choose, possibly?
- What are the apps you can use to access Lemmy, and what are the pros cons you’ve noticed for using them?
- How do you find stuff?
- Any super awesome sub suggestions / lists to follow?
Welcome aboard! Been here a few years.
- Think of Lemmy like a street, and every house is having a little party but they all share back yards. Each instance are the differant houses, they invite and cultivate vibes depending on shared culture. Some houses took down their fences so they can share a bigger back yard (federating), some have reputations for being THAT neighbor and so they put up curtains to block those people out (defederating). Really tho, instances are servers run by private individuals who upkeep and cultivate networks of content like we’re sharing here.
2.-3. I use voyager app on iOS and suggest sh.it just.works as an instance , very chill, federated with the big ones, most of the toxic ones are defederated. Lot of politics but you can filter it out. Voyager can be tweaked in a number of ways, I have mine set up to look like old Reddit style.
-
I struggle with finding a lot of things here. Unfortunately I think there is only so many people, so there’s only so much to find. lot of hollow communities that were set up without any people to fill them when I was joining Lemmy. Look for what’s active and ask around.
-
Niche communities are hard to find because people, but more general places are fairly well populated and lively - Onehundredandninetysix, shitpost, lots of comics like Farside and Calvin and Hobbes.
From my perspective at least, it seems like 95% of the population of Lemmy is citizens of the United States who vote for the Democratic party, and I don’t think that’s bad. However they somehow always manage to steer the conversation, no matter how unrelated it is at the beginning, to United States politics, supporting of course the Democratic party in every circumstance. I have blocked like three mainstream communities of politics and still see this behavior every day. The least I can say about that is that it is weird for sure.
It really is fascinating how different experiences with the threadiverse can be.
That appears to only be Lemmy World. A lot of the other instances are different.
I don’t mind the politics (as I largely fit the demographic) but what bothers me the most is when people post something political with no punchline or humor in that most popular shitpost community. That community is becoming a catchall of anything that people want others to see.
Treat everything here as more public than what you’re used to. Due to the nature of how different instances connect, a lot more information is shared, stored, and visible than what you would expect. For instance your votes are essentially public, even if Lemmy doesn’t display that to you. There are some communities that will block you if you consistently downvote everything in the community.
If you delete anything, that delete action is sent out to every other service/instance, but there’s no guarantee that they will honor that. The large instances do, but there are probably some smaller instances set up for archival purposes.
Mastodon users can post on Threadiverse (Lemmy/PieFed/Mbin) communities. With Lemmy/PieFed you won’t see their Likes/Boosts/Quote stats, and they won’t see your Upvotes/Downvotes.
Lemmy/Mbin accounts aren’t able to see Polls from PieFed/Mastodon users.
Lemmy accounts will only see the first image on posts from other instances that have multiple images.
Some instances block/don’t display downvotes to their users. Beehaw (a lemmy instance) is one of those.
Modlogs are completely public. So, it can help to call out power tripping mods over on [email protected]
As a side note, “delete” on nearly all sites is more like “archive/hide”. If the message is illegal, law enforcement may come knocking, and the site admins need to be able to retrieve it along with relevant metadata.
From memory, if you delete you post/comment, Lemmy only keeps it for some x days that I can’t remember. Maybe 7 or 30.
Not sure how Piefed handles it.
Lemmy has a large Tankie community. Primarily because, Tankies developed Lemmy. Tankie
You can avoid them mostly by blocking their instances, lemmy.ml and lemmygrad.ml ( I have grad wrong, I’ll edit later)
You will still see tankies. You cannot wholly avoid the tankies. But you CAN choose to ignore the tankies.
Oh, and any USA Democrat apologia will get downvoted. Even if you present facts. You can be anti-corpo dem as much as you want, and you’ll STILL get downvoted if it seems too forgiving to Dems.
OH AND ONE LAST THING, have fun.
Edit: Thanks Interstellar_1! Their reply to my post gives the grad instance name.
And .world is FAR up .ml’s ass. They refuse to defederate from them for fear of losing their precious content (admins actually said this), and even advise users to support them financially.
.world isn’t what you think it is. They’re trying HARD to be a Reddit clone.
My account is on .world. I’ve only had to block .ml and that’s been great.
.ml admins are the ones who developed/maintain Lemmy, no?
They are. Yes. I’d advise you make an account on an instance that doesn’t look at .ml as something to aspire to be.
I’m confused, who am I supposed to donate to, to maintain Lemmy dev?
And .world has been fine. I LIKE getting to choose who to block by myself, instead of having the choice made for me?
.world shilled for .ml when they needed donations. And no one here is making choices for you. I ADVISED. Nothing more. .world is a Reddit clone. So if you enjoy having everything you say policed by people with an authoritative definition of “civility”, you are clearly free to.
You asked. I answered. Nothing more.
I guess I’m asking a couple things I’m genuinely curious about.
-
What is policed on .world? I’ve scrubbed their de-federated instances and they seem like the kinda places I wouldn’t want to interact with anyways. I don’t see a ton of PTB level bans/deletes from .world admins, unless I’m missing something?
-
Are there other devs for Lemmy that I can contribute to, that aren’t the .ml Admins? I do dev for work, I appreciate other people doing FOSS work and like to contribute.
They mod like Reddit does. With vague definitions of “civility” and not by content. Meaning, you can spread misinformation, propaganda, and work to disrupt elections. As long as you’re polite about it.
They won’t defederate from .ml because they’re chickenshit and don’t want to lose the traffic. Meaning: they’d rather have these tankie propagandists in the fold- than they’d be bothered to stand up to the bullshit and ban them.
(I know this because I was in on the discussion in the .world mod/admin discord channel)
They also say that we can speak to them to take over communities, but once you bring it to their attention, they vet your history to make sure that you are exactly who they want to be running it. And if not, they install one of their own as moderator.
(Again, I was once a mod there, I was in on the discord chats)
Which translates to: ALL communities on .world belong to the admins and they will install who they want running the communities. VERY Reddit if you ask me.
Also… They remove commments and posts, not because of its content, but because they don’t like being annoyed by reports. Most of the time, they don’t even check for context. They just remove shit because people brigade it. Then they lock the post. Which is exactly what the purpose was all along.
As for contribution, personally, I wouldn’t give a cent to anything I thought would benefit .world or .ml.
-
Hexbear is worse than .ml. Not only because of the authoritarian communist views but also because of its extremely toxic culture of harassment and brigading. The behavior is further empowered by their community mods’ participation, as well as vocal support or awareness and inaction of the instance admins.
At least .ml users seem to have done their reading and operate more calmly in general. Hexbear is basically full of whatever the equivalent of white liberal Twitter is for leftism where it’s more about performing for others with how many terms you can throw around to shout at someone than it is actually engaging with information or ideas.
Hexbear doesn’t attempt to brigade or harrass people, it makes sense you’d be sore if you were banned and people were rude to you, your experience doesn’t fit for everyone though, your view is not necessarily accurate as a generalization.
Incredibly bad faith on your part, as the links contain a lot more than “you were banned and people were rude to you”. Everything seen at my links is common on Hexbear. If really curious (and ready to see a lot of toxicity), I’d advise monitoring their threads in the Slop community for a while to see if I’m wrong. Though even under the false premise that the conduct at my links is irregular, who would want to be connected to a community where even moderators and admins pile on or participate and turn a blind eye to obvious violations of common rules, including their own? It’s not a surprise based on this that most of the biggest Lemmy and PieFed instances have chosen to disconnect from Hexbear. The OP’s .zip is one that doesn’t, so informing them is valuable.
Your comments are removed and I can’t see them on the first link, but from the snippets of quotes from the responses, you’re right, it wasn’t slurs or anyone being rude, I would say the pushback was probably warranted. Most of the people I see in the post about slop I don’t even see post on hexbear, plenty of users there don’t like slop (me included) and there has been mod action against “brigading” before. What’s described as such by commenters is usually not brigading anyway though, it’s the nature of the fediverse that people will post on other instances, things get crossposted all the time, and communists are motivated in their commenting when it comes to nazi propaganda or other condoning of imperialism or capitalism.
My first link is to a comment containing specific examples of rule violations on their part. And do you know why my comments are removed? They revisited that thread after I called out .ml’s propaganda months after that and Hexbear made another Slop thread about that. The web archive link included in my post at the first link still has all my comments. People can see for themselves if I’m right.
Okay I see your comments now, and there is no point to say anything because everything was already debunked, I don’t think your comments should have been removed necessarily but you’re basically arguing from the perspective of literal nazis in the linked post. There has been calls plenty of times to moderated things like death threats more harshly, I’ve seen long time users banned for that sort of thing. So I’m not sure what your complaint is exactly.
People that unironically call leftists “authoritarian communists” repeatedly are going to be banned because it’s a meaningless pejorative and mods don’t have the time to deal with each individual rehashing the same tired bullshit again which has been debunked for literally decades.
the anarchist communities are pretty bad too, IME. even after i blocked the tankies they kept coming at me and telling me how facts are wrong and voting for democrats makes you a baby murderer.
I literally got called a baby murderer just hours ago, because, as I now know, the only brand of hummus that comes in a 16oz container instead of 8oz at my local grocery store, and thus is cheapest per volume, is owned by an Israeli company. so avoid Sabra I guess
i got instance banned from .ml because someone claimed tankies aren’t calling socialists and anarchists “liberals” and i linked them a comment in the same thread where a tankie was doing exactly that. i also called them a lying cunt but w/e, they were being a lying cunt.
that reminds me of the time I saw a .ml thread where someone was saying “China’s not committing genocide against its minority ethnic groups, it’s just setting aside autonomous regions for them. it’d be like if the US set aside a region for the Navajo to govern independently” so I just replied with a screenshot from google maps showing the region that the US has set aside for the Navajo to govern independently, and they downvoted me into the dirt. somehow being reminded of the reality of the exact thing they were describing to support their point made them mad
seriously though, what is wrong with you? don’t you know any product or anyone ever who associated with an Israeli is evil and murders babies? how could you be so morally bankrupt as to not know every product you ever boughts supply chain?
BTW I have dated two Israeli women. Just by reply on my post you are now a Zionist criminal who should be arrested and tried for baby murder!!!
Aww shit my roommate is Jewish and wants to visit Israel when this conflict stops or dies down. I better go hang myself or kick him out so I end up homeless in Wyoming winter
Yeah… I feel like I have mixed experiences with the Anarchists…
We have to better watch out for infiltrators from the tankie community.
Cool punk feelings though IMO.
I’m not sure there’s a respectful way to say this, but that’s probably because people with more reasoned views don’t tend to be pure anarchists
OMG how could you live on the same planet as nazis? That basically makes you a nazi too! Bring on the pitchforks!
Lemmy as a whole is extremely anti-AI, pro-socialism, and pro-LGBT, and the comment sections can be pure freaking insanity.
Because there are significantly fewer people here, there’s considerably more engagement on individual posts. That doesn’t mean the crazies don’t exist, though. They very much do, and there seem to be a disproportionately large number of them.
On Reddit, you can post dozens of comments and receive very little engagement. Here, you can post a single comment and get a massive amount of interaction. That’s the biggest difference I’ve noticed.
I find myself arguing about generally the same things, too. For example, people who are excessively anti-AI often don’t really understand what they’re talking about because they don’t use the technology. They don’t understand what it actually does, what it’s capable of, or what it’s intended to accomplish. As a result, there’s a lot of ignorance you can counter simply by explaining the technology.
Then there’s socialism. A lot of people seem to fundamentally misunderstand what it means. They advocate for socialism while conflating social programs and the economic system itself, as though the two are interchangeable. They’re not.
And, of course, there’s the overwhelming LGBT support. I’m absolutely on board with supporting LGBT rights. People are people. Their sexual orientation shouldn’t define how we view them, but I also don’t think it needs to become someone’s entire personality. Frankly, that’s extremely boring.
It’s basically the antithesis to hackernews around here.
You know how reddit is full of shills, morons, the socially oblivious, and a handful of cool people? Lemmy is like that except the instances nicely divide them for you more or less by category in advance!
Also, I find there is not much middle ground: you pick your minority group (queer, trans, vegan, Linux - [DE, FOSS, security, rice], neurodivergent, leftist / communist / tankie, furry, etc etc), you ramp your idealism to 11, then you comment like you’re 17 and nothing in the world is more important.
You know how Churchill said: “Indeed, it has been said that democracy is the worst form of Government except all those other forms that have been tried from time to time.”? Lemmy is that to it’s alternatives.
The people on Lemmy are smarter I think by whatever average you might take, but as time goes on I’m starting to think the userbase is, on the whole, more irritating than reddit. Just make sure you say “slop” slot and you’ll fit right in.
Bro calls out a bunch of people but leaves out turbolibs and cryptofash, and hangs it on a Churchill quote.
Etc. => et cetera => latin for “and others”
It wasn’t a cryptofash turbolib that showed up, it was, wouldn’t you know it, someone from the named groups, self sorted by instance and with that 17 year old swagger. That’s what I love about .ML: you don’t do anything but bitch on the internet, but at least we can rely on you to show up to prove a point!
It’s nice to be able to block an instance, but I still have to see the edgy and dumb shit the users who call it home comment.
I’d be happy to quote someone besides Churchill, but he happened to make the quote I wanted. Bro can downvote and move on.
I think the “.ml” is another oddity of Lemmy.
On reddit we were all from the same instance. But here we sign up to different servers. So our user names are tagged with a last name from that server. A family as it were. I personally almost never check where people are from but others habitually do. You are allowed to sign up to any server, pick your name.
Idk if I set it or it came that way, but Voyager just shows me the “full name” of everybody all the time.
In the comments or when you click on their name.
I use Voyager too and don’t see the instances
Both places actually. I went looking and there’s a setting for it in appearance that is toggled on for me. Weirdly I don’t see one for everybody and you’re one of the ones I don’t see.
Edit: I bet you don’t see the instance when the user is from the same instance as either you or the community or something like that. No time to check it RN but maybe a theory.
I’m on shitjustworks or something similar
It wasn’t a cryptofash turbolib that showed up
Of course it wasn’t, you’re already here, whining about the mean minorities.
We caught a second one increasingly proving my point.
Pick a minority group, take yourself too seriously, and rage post. Just sign off and go seize the means of production already.
Shit.s.all.cry.pto.fash
Instances are very different and have a higher level of variance than Reddit’s subs.
This place is filled with every form of moron that you’ve ever met on Reddit.
Make use of the block feature liberally.
I just tag people with a 💩 or 🤡 emoji so there’s no weird gaps in comment chains.
Huh, I didn’t realize that’s a feature.
Apparently sync for Android requires a subscription to the pro version for that feature. Is that common? What app are you using?
Boost.
Started using it during the API debacle after RiF got shut off and converted to the Lemmy version when it released.
Looks like Summit also has this feature! (I just discovered it, thanks)
Is there any difference between the two? Like is there some sort of behavior gets a poop emoji rather than a clown emoji? Or do you just use both for “ignore this fool”?
I use the clowns for people that are being asses and the poop for people with shit opinions. Subtle difference, but the clowns are not as severe I guess.
Hello there!
I have literally not blocked any instance, user nor community.
What are y’all doing?













