(Yes, really)

I’d use that for dusting work surfaces while baking.
Could see a use case for a quick roux too
Yeah it could work out like using a colander
The first discovered salt and pepper shakers had a third shaker. No this day, nobody knows what it was used for.
These exist because people wanted and used them. If you can’t figure it out, maybe you’re the dumbass.
Hate to break it to you, but home bakers would use the hell out of both of the weird ones if they also wanted a matched set.
I prefer something a bit better for those ingredients, as the shaker lid present would kinda suck for 80% of what I would use a shaker for.
https://www.amazon.com/CUSINIUM-Powdered-Sugar-Shaker-Duster/dp/B0BQC7Y3X5
That’s the kind of thing that you’d want if you were needing to shake out a dusting of flour, sugar, or other fine ingredients. But if you’d only be needing it once or twice a week? I can see those working fine, as long as it wasn’t high humidity; the type I linked usually have lids you reduce problems from humidity.
Do people still use flour sifters like my Silent Gen mom did? I was led to believe it was 100% neccessary.
Yup. Not for everything, it isn’t going to matter for something like muffins or cupcakes usually. Won’t ever matter for pancakes. But I sift using one of the old fashioned crank sifters like every granny used to have when I need to sift. And it really does matter if you need a fine, evenly distributed flour. It matters when you need to have consistent mass per volume as well.
Now, waaaay back in the day you also had to sift if you didn’t want to eat grit. Stone milling was the default, and you could end up with sizable chunks of rock, and other trash. Nowadays, people differentiate between that as straining and sifting to control baking properties, but it’s the same process.
Anyway. Cakes more than any other type of baking, rely on both precision and flour conditions to give consistent results. Some cakes also fail if the flour isn’t well aerated because the use of leaveners isn’t what gives softness. Think angel food cake as an example. No leavener at all, and if the flour isn’t well sifted, the eggs will collapse, losing all the air you whipped into them.
For other cakes, until you get around to converting things, you’ll run into volumetric recipes. Cups instead of ounces or grams. A cup of well sifted flour is going to be consistent in mass. Can’t remember the number offhand, but something a little over a hundred grams or so. But if you just scoop a cup out of the bag/bin, you can double that mass, maybe even more. So now, instead of that cup of oil that does have the same mass from cup to cup making a nice, moist cake, you end up with a dry brick.
What’s really fun is you have to watch recipes that call for sifting because when you sift matters. A cup of sifted flour is going to weigh approximately the same (+/-a gram or so at the most usually), but a sifted cup of flour is going to be a much heavier thing because it assumes the cup will be scooped out of a container and then sifted, rather than carefully spooned over, or taken from a sifted pile. Guess how I learned that little fact lol.
Plus, you can change outcomes even when it doesn’t matter how precise you are. Making southern style biscuits, you don’t really measure much. I mean, you can, but once you’ve made enough, you don’t need to because you can feel how much flour you’ve put in the bowl, and know how much butter to cut in, and eyeball the liquid.
But if you sift the flour before cutting in the butter/lard/solid fat of choice, you get fluffier biscuits. Angelicly fluffy, like clouds any cherub would nap on. Layer biscuits favor a less airy mix to the point of lumps being okay before rolling out, and flaky style do best with a fork tossed flour after scooping. Just the aeration if the flour changes the outcome, with nothing else changed in the given recipe. That basic idea applies to any baked good, but biscuits are the best example.
Only for specific recipes. I use a large sieve and tap the side with the heel of my hand.




