• 0 Posts
  • 118 Comments
Joined 1 month ago
cake
Cake day: October 11th, 2026

help-circle
  • “China is doing anything remotely close to 19th century colonial practices” Actually, why do you compare today’s CCP to the 19th century actions of some Western kings? Why don’t you compare those actions to Mao’s actions then? Or to some Qing dynasty massacres? “China” is an ethnic mishmash that happens to cover contiguous land; still it is an empire that practices near-colonialism. Just like Russia does. Just like Habsburg Austria did. “Colonialism” doesn’t only apply to cases where the conquerors come by ship.

    Today’s China shows a more civilized outward face, but that is true for the Western countries too. No Belgian king has chopped anyone’s hand for a long time. In an apples to apples comparison, contemporary China is at least as bad, as the contemporary West.

    Oh, and just because you went there: fuck you too, tankie. Your ilk’s obsession with history is the only straw you can cling to.










  • Every empire is expansionist, hence colonial. Not just the Western ones. China is colonizing Africa and parts of Asia. Russia has colonized the entirety of Siberia. Even Iran would like to expand if it could. Waging a war against an empire can be OK, even if it is fought by another empire. Fighting Nazis in WW2 was OK. Kuwait intervention was OK. Intervention in the Yugoslavian civil war was OK. Helping Ukraine against Ruzzia is OK. Mostly because they didn’t provide the USA (and “the West”) with imperial benefits, at least not that was plannable. And the people of the European and Pacific theatres , Kuwait, former Yugoslavia, and Ukraine got (or would get) a better life out of the interventions. As opposed to Iraq and Afghanistan. The problem with those wars were that they were fought for the wrong reasons, mostly greed. It smelled from the start, given that 9/11 was obviously a Saudi plot to destabilize the West, which has been a tremendous success since. Had the USA occupied Saudi Arabia, removed the royal family, put the oil fields under UN control, and made serious efforts, not just half-assed ones, to mend the rift between Islam and the West, e.g. by ensuring that Mecca and the pilgrimage remains unaffected, that would have been a war I would have supported. Had Al Gore’s presidency not been stolen, there was a chance that the USA had gone this way, instead of the money grabbing Afghan and Iraqi wars that the MIC convinced Dubya to do.

    Point is, oppose or support wars based on their premise and goals, not by who is fighting them. I am yet to see a war fought by Ruzzia that was for the good of anyone but the Ruzzian elite. China hasn’t fought wars recently, but their expansion in the Third World is as cruel as the 19th century Western colonialism was.











  • So, this made me read the article https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2452292924000493#b0265 which builds on the methodology of https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-022-32729-8.pdf which further uses the energy and materials estimates established in https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0959378020307512.

    While it makes some gestures toward “renewable energy instead of fossil fuels”, it remains pretty handwavy on the topic of critical non-renewable resources that are going to be the limiting factors. Arable land in cultivable climate, not depleted by overuse of fertilizers (which themselves are non-renewables), non-saline water (desalination is pretty energy intensive), helium, and cheap oil for making plastic, among other things. Reducing consumption was the answer 30 years ago, and even then it just would have slowed the inevitable return to no-fertilizer agriculture (immediate drop in yields), eventually no cheap plastics, no hi-tech chips (helium is essential for today’s photolithography process), etc. We could hope to science our way out, and find some other ways to replace these critical resources, but short of that, the blanket approach of calculating energy and undifferentiated material mass requirements under the current technologies doesn’t say anything about sustainable QOL.