Erased what people exactly? Idk the lore
In 1969 a police raid of a gay bar in New York turned into a riot. Every year since then, there have been marches in memory of the riot. Over the years, the focus has shifted from remembrance to celebration.
I guess OP wants it to return to a more anti-establishment kind of march, rather than a street festival.
I would respond that the fact we can openly celebrate pride shows that progress has been made.
I still feel like there’s so much work to be done, and a party is nice, but having corporate sponsors on pride is just so wrong.
It’s lost it’s ways imho, it got tamed by the establishment from a riot against the police into a festival of consumerism.
Yea agreed on the last point, tx
Marsha P. Johnson was a transgender woman who was a central figure in the Stonewall uprising that Pride parades in the US often commemorate.
I think the poster is suggesting that as transgender people are under attack and the victims of a torrent of bigoted legislation across the country and around the world, they aren’t seeing enough support from other, larger, less-derided queer communities (gay men, lesbian women, etc) considering a trans person kicked off the movement that won them their rights.
But, as a transgender woman myself, I’m not a fan of this framing.
First, it minimizes the efforts of millions of queer people who did the hard work to make the movement happen, at great personal risk, for 50 years, even in the face of an emerging deadly disease (HIV AIDS) that was literally killing generations of its members while the rest of the world looked on.
Second, it’s an attempt to use shame to goose allies into action, and that doesn’t work at scale. It creates division where solidarity is called for.
My state just passed a law requiring that every young girl in the state who wants to play sports must submit to a sex verification examination (just girls mind you, boys are exempt). It passed via a popular vote, so presumably a large number of residents who are ok with queer people and gay marriage also thought it was fine to make every little girl in the state get their genitals verified before playing volleyball for the sole purpose of segregating and excluding the handful of transgender girls who want to join them.
So we have work to do. It’s similar work to what queer people did in the 50 years following Stonewall. We need their help and their wisdom, and I don’t think wagging a finger at them is the best way to get it.



