Disclaimer: I have nothing against remasters. I don’t see OOT as a sacred and perfect thing that nobody’s allowed to touch.

But everyone is swooning over the graphics of the new remaster and I really dislike them. For me, it’s ATBGE: all technics and no art direction.

Sure, the physics are impressive, the texture high res, and the models detailed. But they’re too detailed. It looks like they’ve taken any flat surface and said “ooh, we need to add some detail here”.

So you’re left with something cartoony but with very realistic texture, shaders etc. There’s a mismatch in style between the big geometry of OOT models that they’ve kept and the small geometry they’ve added on top of them. On the other hand, Elden Rings also has an ultra detailed style and I’ve got no problem with it because it’s not trying to be cartoony at the same time.

I’ve found this mismatch repugnant as well, because it reminds me if genAI. I’m not saying they used AI, but when you ask one to “improve” a cartoon, you end up with something similar: it adds unnecessary detail e-ve-ry-where.

  • cheat700000007@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    6 days ago

    I did enjoy botw itself, it could have been a sweet love letter to the original if they didn’t bork the dungeons so badly and actually had things to discover with mechanical functionality, but its legacy has done so much damage.

    It’s like gears of war popularizing no color for the 360 era plus fucking forced walk and talk sections. Just make it a god damn cutscene that’s skippable.

    • NovaVeles@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      6 days ago

      The reasons people want to skip cut-scene is because most of them are rubbish. It was the title Ryse on Xbox One/PC, it isn’t the greatest game and it can be finished in about 5 hours, but they got the cut-scene just right in that you actually didn’t want to skip them.

        • NovaVeles@lemmy.world
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          2
          ·
          edit-2
          5 days ago

          So yeah, used to work in the industry (contractor engine coding/tooling - nothing of note), that decision almost always comes from the director at the top because they want people to endure their story creation and vision. It is there only to stroke their ego.

          There are those cut scene that become skip-able half way through are just used to cover load, that is a reasonable middle ground. Mirrors edge did that well enough by just run a video while the work is done in the background and I do wonder how quick that would run nowadays on a PC with an SSD and a decent CPU rushing through decompression rather than the slow as molasses memory systems we had on the 360/Ps3.